An Excellent Game
--The Good--
The sound in this game was absolutely superb. You could hear everything pretty much perfectly, and the guitars and drums were great. Even in the speaking parts of this game, everything sounded great; nice job! There was also A LOT of interactivity in this game; the ability to create-your-own-beat (which is basically the whole game) was great and very fun. The graphics were actually pretty good... the guitars and drums were drawn very well, as were the musicians, and the people in the 'Dude!!' section of this game. There was some violence in this flash... the 'Dude!!' section once again, which may or may not be a good thing...
--The Improvement-Needing--
Well, I think it would have been a nice addition to have a singer, or have one of the guitarists singing. The ability to wite out your own lyrics, and hear the guys singing them would be cool. Maybe even a voice selector, out of many options...?. Oh well, for, 'Punk-O-Matic 2' (if it ever [and hopefully] gets made]). Also, the 'Dude!!' section of this game, while pretty well-animated, seemed slightly pointless too me. I'm not saying it sholudn't be there, I just think that it's kind of random... which is kind of a good thing, depending on how you look at it. There wasn't a lot of humour in this flash, whcih doesn't really matter, I guess. Also, more than 3 save slots would be nice, but that's (Kind of) just a minor complaint... I found myself wanting to save all of the beats I created!
--Overall--
Overall I gave this game a 9. This is a superb game that is very fun to play, too. The sound and graphics and style in this game were great. There was tons of interactivity in this gmae, too. It could use A LITTLE improving (maybe a lyrics maker, and maybe some mroe save slots), but those are just minor additions you could add to the game. Nice job!